Bibliographic Information
Article Title
“I Like to Keep my Archaeology Dead”. Alienation and Othering of the Past as an Ethical Problem
Journal Title
Canadian Journal of Bioethics
Author(s)
Schreiber Stefan, and Neumann Sabine, and Egbers Vera
Month of Publication
November
Year of Publication
2019
Volume Number
2
Issue Number
3
Article Pages
88-96
Web Address (URL)
Additional Information
Available Through
erudit
Language
English
Notes
Abstract:
"As archaeologists, we have to deal with the dead, and as David Clarke once said, we like to keep our archaeology dead. From an epistemological perspective, alienation from the dead seems almost inevitable; otherwise, we would only project today’s conditions onto the past. Therefore, the past must be, and must remain, a foreign country. These alienating processes have ethical implications, however, especially when it comes to the study of human remains. In this article, we analyze the structures within the scientific discipline of archaeology that normalize practices, such as the labeling of human bone material during excavations and the object-like display of skeletons in museums. We argue that archaeologists have an – often rejected – ethical responsibility towards subjects from the past. We, therefore, seek to open up a debate concerning alternative strategies for the treatment of the dead."
Taxonomies
CIfA Codes
Keywords & Terms
- Anti-Commercialization
- Burials and Human Remains
- Conflicts of Interest
- Do No Harm
- ICOMOS
- Impact on Communities - Local, Descendant, etc.
- Repatriation
- Respect for and Responsibility to Affected Groups
- Storage of Data, Specimens, and Records
Topics & Issues
- Decolonizing Archaeology
- Descendant, Resident, and Stakeholder Communities
- Ethical Dilemmas
- Ethical Responsibilities of Archaeologists
- Ethics of Collecting
- Human Remains and Ethical Practice
- Indigenous Archaeology: Perspectives and Issues
- Museum and Display Ethics
- NAGPRA, Repatriation, and Indigenous Rights