Bibliographic Information
Article Title
Ethics, Not Objects
Journal Title
Cambridge Archaeological Journal
Author(s)
Van Dyke, Ruth
Year of Publication
2021
Article Pages
1-7
Web Address (URL)
Additional Information
Available Through
Cambridge University Press
Language
English
Notes
Posthumanist or new materialist tools, positions and conversations contain some useful ideas for archaeologists to think with, but others that I find deeply problematic. In this opinion piece, I organize my thoughts around three posthumanist ‘turns’ to objects and materials, relations and assemblages, and non-human animacy. I appreciate how some strands of Posthumanism can help us think more creatively and thoughtfully about relations between humans and non-humans, but I argue against non-anthropocentrism, flat ontology and symmetrical archaeology. Animacy and perspectivism can help remedy colonialist and late-stage capitalist destructive forces, but archaeologists should take care not simply to appropriate, patronize, or re-colonize non-western thinkers. Ultimately, I argue, we should not need continental philosophy to remind us to care about one other, all living creatures and the well-being of our shared planet. What is needed today are ethics, not convoluted turns toward objects.
Taxonomies
RPA Codes & Standards
- Adequate Preparation for Research Projects
- Appropriate Dissemination of Research
- Integrity of Research Methodology
- Procedures for Field Survey or Excavation
CIfA Codes
- Principle 1: Adherence to ethical and responsible behaviour in archaeological affairs
- Principle 3: Responsibility for acquiring and recording reliable information of the past in archaeological research
- Principle 4: Responsibility for the availability of archaeological results within reasonable dispatch
Keywords & Terms
- Burials and Human Remains
- Conservation
- Consultation/Partnership with Affected Groups
- Consultation/Partnership with Indigenous Peoples
- General Archaeological Ethics
- Preservation of Archaeological Resources
- Professional Standards
- Respect for and Responsibility to Affected Groups
- Standards of Data Collection, Recordation, Analysis
- Storage of Data, Specimens, and Records
Topics & Issues
- Applied Archaeology
- Archaeological Education
- Biological Anthropology/Archaeology
- Colonialism and Imperialism
- Community Archaeology and Participatory Research
- Decolonizing Archaeology
- Descendant, Resident, and Stakeholder Communities
- Ethical Case Studies
- Ethical Dilemmas
- Ethics of Collecting
- Heritage Management
- NAGPRA, Repatriation, and Indigenous Rights
- Professionalism and Professional Standards